Quickly create live databases for the web. Click here for Netiva!
| Navigational map -- for text only please go to the bottom of the page ||Forums|
Readers' Choice Awards (siteadm) Fri, 13 Jun
What Poll? (forum) Sat, 14 Jun
Another poll was held?? (up_yours) Mon, 16 Jun
Big Name Computer Company (rparker) Mon, 16 Jun
Rubbish!!! (Yaztromo) Mon, 16 Jun
Yes, I call it valid (rparker) Mon, 16 Jun

You're wrong.

Posted by: CRConrad
Date posted: Tue Jun 17 9:02:19 PDT 1997

Rachel, you write:

> Remember that InfoWorld is written for IS managers in various businesses -- but not the
> IT industry (software developers, chip makers, and systems manufacturers, and the like).

I have an IT job at a non-IT company; I make my living as a programmer. Funny, I feel I'm in the IT business, not the pointy-haired managing business.


> We try to let our target readers vote -- once a year -- on the products that they choose and use. We disqualified all vendors
> -- big and small. I don't see how that makes our conclusions less statistically valid given who we say our audience is.

Interesting choice of words, "given who _y_o_u_ _s_a_y_ your audience is" . . .
So I guess we can take the "Readers' Choice" as given from above by the powers that be, too:
It darn well better be what _y_o_u_ _s_a_y_ it should be, or the results get thrown out, right?

Yes, of course that's "statistically valid"; only, as a picture of *what*? A 100% true description of the results _y_o_u_ _w_a_n_t_e_d_ -- no more, no less.


Oh, and by the way, was it only _v_e_n_d_o_r_s_ who were excluded, or their customers, too?
In "Big Name Computer Company" (Posted by: rparker Date posted: Mon, 16 Jun 1997), you write:
>> Here's why we chose readers outside the IT field: Say Big Name Computer Company finds out that its product is being considered for this award,
and suggests to all of its employees, suppliers, and *BUSINESS PARTNERS* that a smart thing to do would be to be sure to vote for its product.
HMMM. What if it even offered a financial incentive to the employee who got the most votes cast. All legitimate votes, of course. << [My emphasis]

In business newspeak, everybody who _b_u_y_s_ a computer or a program is surely a "business partner"
of the vendor in question, so I don't see who would be *left* as the target population of your survey . . .

Those who neither make _o_r_ _u_s_e_ IT products?!?
Well, if nothing else, it shows which lengths you had to go to, in order to get the results you wanted . . .


Christian R. Conrad


Respond | Search | Help


For questions or comments, email the Forums Editor

kristin_kueter@infoworld.com